This page is not legal advice. It does not apply the law to a campaign, a recording, a tip, or a document in hand. It points at public statutes, a Federal Election Commission explanation, one Supreme Court decision, and two reported ethics conversations, and it says what each of those sources covers. A campaign with a live question takes that question to its own lawyer. The research method, separate from the legal question, is opposition research.

What "is it legal" gets wrong

Search results often answer with a moral essay or a single anecdote. Both can be useful, and neither is a code section. "Opposition research" is a campaign phrase. Federal election law regulates contributions, expenditures, and foreign nationals. Criminal law regulates unauthorized computer access, and other statutes regulate recording and trespass, which this page does not restate statute by statute. Constitutional law limits some government attempts to punish false speech. Those are different questions. A sentence that says "oppo is legal if it is true" mixes them.

The practical split used on this site is about sources, not about a permission slip. Opposition research sources names the public records a file can cite: finance filings, roll calls, disclosures, court records, and the candidate's own statements. FEC candidate research is the federal money file. Campaign finance is the schedule pass. Public records is the court and records pass. None of those pages is a legal opinion. They are instructions for opening a document and citing it.

Public records are not a grant of every method

A filing that an agency publishes can be read. That sentence does not describe how the filing was obtained. Buying a published report, using a public search portal, and filing a records request are different procedures from guessing a password, using someone else's credentials, or bypassing an access wall.

The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act is 18 U.S.C. § 1030. Subsection (a)(2) covers someone who intentionally accesses a computer without authorization, or exceeds authorized access, and thereby obtains information from a protected computer, from a financial institution, or from a federal department or agency, among other branches of that subsection. The statute is longer than that clause, and it includes intent elements this page will not paraphrase into a checklist of safe tricks. The point for a research desk is the category. Unauthorized access is a computer-crime question. It is not "aggressive opposition research." The text is at Cornell's copy of 18 U.S.C. § 1030.

Federal records requests are a statute, and states have their own

The Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C. § 552, requires federal agencies to make certain information public and, on a request that reasonably describes the records and follows the agency's published rules, to make records promptly available, subject to exemptions. A congressional finding reprinted with the statute says the purpose is to make agency information available for public inspection, subject to those exemptions, for any public or private purpose. The text is at Cornell's copy of 5 U.S.C. § 552.

FOIA is a federal agency statute. A county court, a city clerk, and a state election office are not FOIA desks merely because someone uses the phrase "freedom of information." Their records follow the state constitution and the state public-records or open-records law, plus the office's own rules. Name the office. Cite the record that came back. An empty response is a result. It is not permission to reconstruct the missing file from a blog.

Paying for research is not the same as accepting a thing of value

Campaigns pay vendors and staff to read public records. A disbursement for research, reported by a federal committee, is a filing fact a reader can look up in the FEC record. How to read the report is FEC candidate research. The existence of paid research is not a secret. The legal question that recurs is the unpaid packet.

Under 11 C.F.R. § 100.52(a), a gift of money or anything of value made for the purpose of influencing a federal election is a contribution. Section 100.52(d)(1) says "anything of value" includes in-kind contributions, and that the provision of goods or services without charge, or at less than the usual and normal charge, is a contribution unless an exemption applies. The regulation's examples include personnel and lists. The usual and normal charge for services, other than an unpaid volunteer, is the hourly or piecework charge at a commercially reasonable rate at the time. The text is 11 C.F.R. § 100.52.

That regulation does not say the words "opposition research." It says goods and services. Whether a particular memo, list, or investigation is a service, and whether the charge was the usual and normal one, is a facts question. This page does not grade a vendor invoice.

Foreign nationals and a thing of value

52 U.S.C. § 30121(a) makes it unlawful for a foreign national, directly or indirectly, to make a contribution or donation of money or other thing of value, or to promise to make one, in connection with a federal, state, or local election, and for a person to solicit, accept, or receive that contribution or donation from a foreign national. The section also covers contributions to a party committee and certain expenditures and electioneering communications. "Foreign national" is defined in the statute and excludes a citizen of the United States. The text is 52 U.S.C. § 30121.

The FEC's public page states the same prohibition in operational language: federal law prohibits contributions, donations, expenditures, and disbursements solicited, directed, received, or made by or from foreign nationals in connection with any federal, state, or local election. It also describes a ban on foreign nationals participating in decisions about election-related activities, and a ban on knowingly providing substantial assistance. The page is FEC: Foreign nationals. The regulation is 11 C.F.R. § 110.20.

Commissioners Shana M. Broussard and Ellen L. Weintraub, in a statement of reasons in MURs 7645, 7663, and 7705, wrote that opposition research is a service campaigns commonly buy, and that the provision of free opposition research may constitute a contribution. They pointed to MUR 5409, where they said the Commission found a corporation made prohibited in-kind contributions by giving a campaign lists the corporation had compiled. Their statement also says three colleagues voted against moving forward and the Commission did not go forward on the Ukraine allegations in those MURs. The statement is theirs. It is not a court opinion, and it is not a Commission finding in the matters where the Commission did not proceed. Read it as a statement of reasons: FEC PDF, MUR 7645.

A desk can still use the statute without adopting that statement. Do not solicit or accept a thing of value from a foreign national in connection with an election. Do not treat "it was only information" as a phrase that erases "other thing of value" from section 30121. If the question is whether a specific offer is a contribution, that is the lawyer's question, not a blog's.

False speech is not a single rule

People ask whether a true finding may be said, and whether a false one is a crime. The First Amendment cases do not collapse into a campaign slogan.

In United States v. Alvarez, 567 U.S. 709 (2012), the Supreme Court affirmed the judgment that the Stolen Valor Act, which criminalized falsely claiming military medals, infringed the First Amendment. The syllabus on the Library of Congress copy says Justice Kennedy's plurality concluded the Act infringed protected speech, and that the Court's prior cases had not recognized a general First Amendment exception for false statements as such. The U.S. Courts educational page summarizes the holding in part this way: falsity alone may not be enough to exclude speech from First Amendment protection. The decision is United States v. Alvarez on GovInfo. The educational summary is U.S. Courts: holding in U.S. v. Alvarez.

The National Conference of State Legislatures, on its fair campaign practices page, says state laws restricting campaign speech, even false speech, may face constitutional challenges, and it cites Alvarez for the point that laws restricting speech purely because it is false may be unconstitutional. That is NCSL's description of the litigation risk. It is not a holding that every false campaign sentence is protected, and it is not a holding that every false sentence is legal. Defamation, fraud, and other categories the Alvarez plurality listed as historically unprotected are outside this page. NCSL's page is Fair Campaign Practice Laws.

What a research desk can do without practicing law is refuse to ship a sentence the record does not contain. The methodology keeps a claim off a public page when the cited document does not still say the cited thing. That is a publication rule. It is not a substitute for the First Amendment analysis above.

Ethics conversations that are not statutes

The Markkula Center for Applied Ethics published "The Ethics of Opposition Research." It argues that information a campaign uses should be true, fair, and relevant if the aim is an informed electorate. It treats a voting record, and a recording of a candidate's own public statements, as ordinary. It treats research into the private lives of a candidate's family or associates as generally outside ethical norms, because those people did not stand for office. It says relevance is the harder middle, and it gives examples, a long-ago traffic case on one side and a conflict with the candidate's own platform on the other, without pretending the examples are rules. It says research should come from legally available sources, and it names trespass, burglary, illegal wiretaps, and hacking as out of bounds. The essay is Markkula Center.

PBS NewsHour aired "The ethical dos and don'ts of opposition research" on July 13, 2017. The guests were practitioners, not a court. One described a rule of thumb, "if you can cite it, you can write it," and a publicly available source. The same conversation warned about medical records, about repeating a claim that is not true, and about information from a hostile government. A guest described the Gore campaign receiving a Bush debate book and calling the FBI rather than using the book. Those are reported judgments from that broadcast. They are not elements of a statute. The page is PBS NewsHour.

Use the essays as ethics, and the statutes as statutes. Do not cite Markkula for what 52 U.S.C. § 30121 says. Do not cite the FEC for whether a sibling's divorce is "fair."

A comparison of the limits

QuestionWhere to readWhat the source doesWhat this page will not do
May a foreign national give a thing of value in connection with an election?52 U.S.C. § 30121 and the FEC foreign-nationals pageStates a prohibition on making, and on soliciting, accepting, or receiving, that contribution or donationDecide whether a specific email is a solicitation
When is a free service an in-kind contribution?11 C.F.R. § 100.52(d)Defines anything of value to include goods or services below the usual and normal charge, with a volunteer exceptionPrice a vendor or classify a volunteer
What is unauthorized computer access?18 U.S.C. § 1030Defines federal computer-access offenses, including obtaining information from a protected computer without authorizationList bypass techniques or bless a tool
How does a person request federal agency records?5 U.S.C. § 552Sets a request process and exemptions for federal agenciesTurn a state court into a FOIA desk
May government punish false speech because it is false?United States v. Alvarez and the NCSL summaryThe Stolen Valor Act fell; falsity alone is not a general exception. NCSL flags similar risk for state campaign-speech lawsApply defamation law to a draft sentence
Is a family member's private life fair game?Markkula Center essayAn ethics argument that it generally is notInvent a privilege statute the essay does not cite

A limit checklist that stays inside the sources

1. Name the statute or the essay before the conclusion. "30121" and "Markkula" are not interchangeable. 2. If the material came from a foreign national, stop and ask counsel before it enters the file as a usable product. Do not workshop the phrase "thing of value" in a group chat and treat the result as an answer. This page is not that advice. 3. If the material sits behind a login that is not the researcher's, treat access as a question, not as a find. Section 1030 is the federal computer statute to hand to counsel. 4. If the material is a federal agency record that is not already public, the request path is 5 U.S.C. § 552, with exemptions. If it is a state or local record, name that state's process. 5. If the sentence describes a spouse, a child, or another person who is not the candidate, Markkula's relevance question is the ethics flag. The flag is not a court order. 6. If the sentence goes past the document, cut it or mark it as a question. The citation practice is source citations in political research. 7. Do not attach this analysis to a person merely because the person is on a ballot. For 2026 governor, Senate, and House nominees, the name starts on the certified nominees file, taken from official state lists. A legal limit is about the method. It is not a biographical fact about the nominee.

The how-to for the campaign's own file is how to do self-opposition research before launch. This page is not that method, and it is not legal advice.

References

52 U.S.C. § 30121, law.cornell.edu.

11 C.F.R. § 100.52, law.cornell.edu.

11 C.F.R. § 110.20, law.cornell.edu.

FEC, "Foreign nationals," fec.gov.

Statement of Reasons of Commissioners Broussard and Weintraub, MURs 7645, 7663, and 7705, fec.gov PDF.

18 U.S.C. § 1030, law.cornell.edu.

5 U.S.C. § 552, law.cornell.edu.

United States v. Alvarez, 567 U.S. 709 (2012), GovInfo.

U.S. Courts, holding summary, uscourts.gov.

National Conference of State Legislatures, "Fair Campaign Practice Laws," ncsl.org.

Markkula Center for Applied Ethics, "The Ethics of Opposition Research," scu.edu.

PBS NewsHour, "The ethical dos and don'ts of opposition research," pbs.org.

FAQs

Is opposition research legal in the United States?

There is no single statute titled opposition research. Public filings, roll calls, and court records are collected in ordinary campaign work. Other acts, including a foreign national's thing of value and unauthorized computer access, are restricted by statutes cited on this page. This page is not legal advice, and a campaign with a live question should ask its own lawyer.

Can a campaign accept free opposition research from a foreign national?

Federal law makes it unlawful for a foreign national to give a contribution or donation of money or other thing of value in connection with a federal, state, or local election, and for a person to solicit, accept, or receive that contribution or donation. The FEC states the same prohibition. Whether a particular packet is a thing of value is a facts question. This page does not decide a pending matter.

Does the First Amendment ban every false campaign statement?

No. In United States v. Alvarez, 567 U.S. 709 (2012), the Supreme Court affirmed that the Stolen Valor Act infringed the First Amendment. The U.S. Courts educational summary says falsity alone may not be enough to exclude speech from First Amendment protection. The National Conference of State Legislatures warns that state laws restricting campaign speech, even false speech, may face constitutional challenges. Defamation and fraud remain separate bodies of law. This page does not apply them to a fact pattern.

Is a public-records request the same as hacking?

No. The Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C. 552, is a request process for federal agency records, with exemptions. State and local records follow state law, not that federal statute. The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 U.S.C. 1030, addresses unauthorized access to computers. Opening a government portal that publishes a filing is not the same act as bypassing an access control. The shelves for ordinary records are listed in opposition research sources.